Before you spend anything on AI, you should be able to answer one question: what will this return, and when? Here is a simple framework you can use in about 30 minutes with a spreadsheet.
Step 1: Pick one process
Choose a single high-volume, repetitive process. The best candidates:
- happen every day
- take more than a few minutes each time
- follow a predictable pattern
- don't need creative judgement
Examples: entering invoices, sorting incoming emails, answering routine support questions, preparing weekly reports.
Step 2: Calculate today's cost
Annual cost = time per task (hours) × hourly cost of the person × tasks per day × working days per year
Step 3: Estimate the saving honestly
Automation rarely handles 100% of cases. Estimate what share of the volume can be handled without a person, based on a sample of real cases, and stay conservative. Remember that someone still checks exceptions.
Annual saving = annual cost × share automated − time still spent on checking and exceptions
Step 4: Add the full cost of the solution
Include the build cost, monthly running costs (AI usage, hosting, software licences) and maintenance time. Then:
Payback period (months) = build cost ÷ (monthly saving − monthly running cost)
As a rule of thumb, a payback under 12 to 18 months is usually worth a closer look.
Worked example
An illustrative example, not a client result: a finance assistant spends 15 minutes on each of 40 invoices a day.
- Time: 0.25 hours × 40 invoices × 250 days = 2,500 hours a year
- At $30 an hour, that is $75,000 a year
- If a tested pilot shows 70% can be processed automatically, and checking exceptions takes 300 hours a year, the saving is about $52,500 − $9,000 = $43,500 a year, or about $3,600 a month
- If the build costs $15,000 and running costs are $300 a month, payback is $15,000 ÷ $3,300, about 4.5 months
Swap in your own numbers. If the result only works with optimistic assumptions, pick a different process.
Key takeaway
Do the maths first, test with a small pilot, then build. Want a second opinion on your numbers? Book a free 30-minute call.